/- Copyright 2026 The Formal Conjectures Authors. Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License"); you may not use this file except in compliance with the License. You may obtain a copy of the License at https://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0 Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS, WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied. See the License for the specific language governing permissions and limitations under the License. -/ module public import FormalConjecturesUtil

Serre's multiplicity conjectures

Let $R$ be a regular local ring and let $M$, $N$ be finitely generated $R$-modules such that $M \otimes_R N$ has finite length. Serre defined the intersection multiplicity $$\chi(M, N) = \sum_{i \ge 0} (-1)^i \ell_R(\operatorname{Tor}_i^R(M, N)).$$ He proved the dimension inequality $\dim M + \dim N \le \dim R$ for every regular local ring, and conjectured the following three properties:

    Non-negativity: $\chi(M, N) \ge 0$.

    Vanishing: if $\dim M + \dim N < \dim R$, then $\chi(M, N) = 0$.

    Positivity: if $\dim M + \dim N = \dim R$, then $\chi(M, N) > 0$.

Serre proved all three when $R$ is of equal characteristic, or of mixed characteristic and unramified. Vanishing was proved in general by Roberts and, independently, by Gillet and Soulé. Non-negativity was proved in general by Gabber. Positivity is open in general. For Serre's two special cases, this file states only positivity, since non-negativity and vanishing are now known in general.

The intersection multiplicity is Module.intersectionMultiplicity, defined in FormalConjecturesForMathlib.RingTheory.IntersectionMultiplicity.

References:

    Wikipedia

    [Se00] J.-P. Serre, Local algebra, Springer Monographs in Mathematics, Springer, 2000, Chapter V, Part B.

    [Ro85] P. Roberts, The vanishing of intersection multiplicities of perfect complexes, Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 13 (1985), 127–130.

    [GS87] H. Gillet, C. Soulé, Intersection theory using Adams operations, Invent. Math. 90 (1987), 243–277.

    [Ro98] P. Roberts, Recent developments on Serre's multiplicity conjectures: Gabber's proof of the nonnegativity conjecture, Enseign. Math. 44 (1998), 305–324.

    [Sk19] C. Skalit, Positivity of intersection multiplicity over a two-dimensional base, J. Pure Appl. Algebra 223 (2019), 1801–1816. arXiv:1510.05146

@[expose] public sectionopen IsLocalRing Module TensorProductnamespace SerreMultiplicityConjecturesuniverse uvariable (R : Type u) [CommRing R] [IsRegularLocalRing R] (M N : Type u) [AddCommGroup M] [Module R M] [Module.Finite R M] [AddCommGroup N] [Module R N] [Module.Finite R N]

Dimension inequality. Let $R$ be a regular local ring and let $M$, $N$ be finitely generated $R$-modules such that $M \otimes_R N$ has finite length. Then $\dim M + \dim N \le \dim R$. Proved by Serre for every regular local ring [Se00].

@[category research solved, AMS 13 14] theorem supportDim_add_supportDim_le_ringKrullDim (h : IsFiniteLength R (M ⊗[R] N)) : Module.supportDim R M + Module.supportDim R N ≤ ringKrullDim R := R:Type uinst✝⁷:CommRing Rinst✝⁶:IsRegularLocalRing RM:Type uN:Type uinst✝⁵:AddCommGroup Minst✝⁴:Module R Minst✝³:Module.Finite R Minst✝²:AddCommGroup Ninst✝¹:Module R Ninst✝:Module.Finite R Nh:IsFiniteLength R (M ⊗[R] N)⊢ supportDim R M + supportDim R N ≤ ringKrullDim R All goals completed! 🐙

Non-negativity. Let $R$ be a regular local ring and let $M$, $N$ be finitely generated $R$-modules such that $M \otimes_R N$ has finite length. Then $\chi(M, N) \ge 0$. Conjectured by Serre and proved by Gabber in 1995 [Ro98].

@[category research solved, AMS 13 14] theorem intersectionMultiplicity_nonneg (h : IsFiniteLength R (M ⊗[R] N)) : 0 ≤ intersectionMultiplicity R M N := R:Type uinst✝⁷:CommRing Rinst✝⁶:IsRegularLocalRing RM:Type uN:Type uinst✝⁵:AddCommGroup Minst✝⁴:Module R Minst✝³:Module.Finite R Minst✝²:AddCommGroup Ninst✝¹:Module R Ninst✝:Module.Finite R Nh:IsFiniteLength R (M ⊗[R] N)⊢ 0 ≤ intersectionMultiplicity R M N All goals completed! 🐙

Vanishing. Let $R$ be a regular local ring and let $M$, $N$ be finitely generated $R$-modules such that $M \otimes_R N$ has finite length. If $\dim M + \dim N < \dim R$, then $\chi(M, N) = 0$. Conjectured by Serre and proved by Roberts [Ro85] and, independently, by Gillet and Soulé [GS87].

@[category research solved, AMS 13 14] theorem intersectionMultiplicity_eq_zero_of_lt (h : IsFiniteLength R (M ⊗[R] N)) (hdim : Module.supportDim R M + Module.supportDim R N < ringKrullDim R) : intersectionMultiplicity R M N = 0 := R:Type uinst✝⁷:CommRing Rinst✝⁶:IsRegularLocalRing RM:Type uN:Type uinst✝⁵:AddCommGroup Minst✝⁴:Module R Minst✝³:Module.Finite R Minst✝²:AddCommGroup Ninst✝¹:Module R Ninst✝:Module.Finite R Nh:IsFiniteLength R (M ⊗[R] N)hdim:supportDim R M + supportDim R N < ringKrullDim R⊢ intersectionMultiplicity R M N = 0 All goals completed! 🐙

Positivity conjecture. Let $R$ be a regular local ring and let $M$, $N$ be finitely generated $R$-modules such that $M \otimes_R N$ has finite length. If $\dim M + \dim N = \dim R$, then $\chi(M, N) > 0$.

The hypothesis on dimensions forces $M$ and $N$ to be nonzero, since the dimension of the zero module is $\bot$.

@[category research open, AMS 13 14] theorem intersectionMultiplicity_pos (h : IsFiniteLength R (M ⊗[R] N)) (hdim : Module.supportDim R M + Module.supportDim R N = ringKrullDim R) : 0 < intersectionMultiplicity R M N := R:Type uinst✝⁷:CommRing Rinst✝⁶:IsRegularLocalRing RM:Type uN:Type uinst✝⁵:AddCommGroup Minst✝⁴:Module R Minst✝³:Module.Finite R Minst✝²:AddCommGroup Ninst✝¹:Module R Ninst✝:Module.Finite R Nh:IsFiniteLength R (M ⊗[R] N)hdim:supportDim R M + supportDim R N = ringKrullDim R⊢ 0 < intersectionMultiplicity R M N All goals completed! 🐙

Positivity conjecture, in the form stated on Wikipedia. Let $R$ be a regular local ring and let $P$, $Q$ be prime ideals of $R$ such that $R/P \otimes_R R/Q$ has finite length. If $\dim R/P + \dim R/Q = \dim R$, then $\chi(R/P, R/Q) > 0$.

@[category research open, AMS 13 14] theorem intersectionMultiplicity_pos_quotient (P Q : Ideal R) [P.IsPrime] [Q.IsPrime] (h : IsFiniteLength R ((R ⧸ P) ⊗[R] (R ⧸ Q))) (hdim : ringKrullDim (R ⧸ P) + ringKrullDim (R ⧸ Q) = ringKrullDim R) : 0 < intersectionMultiplicity R (R ⧸ P) (R ⧸ Q) := R:Type uinst✝³:CommRing Rinst✝²:IsRegularLocalRing RP:Ideal RQ:Ideal Rinst✝¹:P.IsPrimeinst✝:Q.IsPrimeh:IsFiniteLength R ((R ⧸ P) ⊗[R] (R ⧸ Q))hdim:ringKrullDim (R ⧸ P) + ringKrullDim (R ⧸ Q) = ringKrullDim R⊢ 0 < intersectionMultiplicity R (R ⧸ P) (R ⧸ Q) All goals completed! 🐙

Serre proved the positivity conjecture when $R$ is of equal characteristic, that is, when $R$ contains a field [Se00].

@[category research solved, AMS 13 14] theorem intersectionMultiplicity_pos_of_equalCharacteristic (k : Type*) [Field k] [Algebra k R] (h : IsFiniteLength R (M ⊗[R] N)) (hdim : Module.supportDim R M + Module.supportDim R N = ringKrullDim R) : 0 < intersectionMultiplicity R M N := R:Type uinst✝⁹:CommRing Rinst✝⁸:IsRegularLocalRing RM:Type uN:Type uinst✝⁷:AddCommGroup Minst✝⁶:Module R Minst✝⁵:Module.Finite R Minst✝⁴:AddCommGroup Ninst✝³:Module R Ninst✝²:Module.Finite R Nk:Type u_1inst✝¹:Field kinst✝:Algebra k Rh:IsFiniteLength R (M ⊗[R] N)hdim:supportDim R M + supportDim R N = ringKrullDim R⊢ 0 < intersectionMultiplicity R M N All goals completed! 🐙

Serre proved the positivity conjecture when $R$ is of mixed characteristic and unramified, that is, when the characteristic $p$ of the residue field is not in the square of the maximal ideal of $R$ [Se00]. The hypothesis $p \notin \mathfrak m^2$ excludes $p = 0$ and the equal characteristic case, where $p = 0$ in $R$.

@[category research solved, AMS 13 14] theorem intersectionMultiplicity_pos_of_unramified (p : ℕ) [CharP (ResidueField R) p] (hp : (p : R) ∉ maximalIdeal R ^ 2) (h : IsFiniteLength R (M ⊗[R] N)) (hdim : Module.supportDim R M + Module.supportDim R N = ringKrullDim R) : 0 < intersectionMultiplicity R M N := R:Type uinst✝⁸:CommRing Rinst✝⁷:IsRegularLocalRing RM:Type uN:Type uinst✝⁶:AddCommGroup Minst✝⁵:Module R Minst✝⁴:Module.Finite R Minst✝³:AddCommGroup Ninst✝²:Module R Ninst✝¹:Module.Finite R Np:ℕinst✝:CharP (ResidueField R) php:↑p ∉ maximalIdeal R ^ 2h:IsFiniteLength R (M ⊗[R] N)hdim:supportDim R M + supportDim R N = ringKrullDim R⊢ 0 < intersectionMultiplicity R M N All goals completed! 🐙end SerreMultiplicityConjectures