/-
Copyright 2026 The Formal Conjectures Authors.
Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
You may obtain a copy of the License at
https://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
limitations under the License.
-/
module
public import FormalConjecturesUtilConjectures around homogeneous topological spaces
This file formalizes the notions of a homogeneous topological space and of (ω-)monolithic topological spaces, and states some open problems about homogeneous and monolithic compact spaces.
References:
[Ar2013] Arhangeliski, Alexandr. "Selected old open problems in general topology." Buletinul Academiei de Ştiinţe a Republicii Moldova. Matematica 73.2-3 (2013): 37-46. https://www.math.md/files/basm/y2013-n2-3/y2013-n2-3-(pp37-46).pdf.pdf
[Ar1987] Arhangel'skii, A. V. "Topological homogeneity. Topological groups and their continuous images." Russian Mathematical Surveys 42.2 (1987): 83-131. https://doi.org/10.1070/RM1987v042n02ABEH001333
@[expose] public sectionopen TopologicalSpace Topology Filter Setopen scoped Cardinalnamespace HomogeneousA topological space $X$ is called homogeneous if for all $x, y \in X$ there is homeomorphism $f : X \to X$ with $f(x) = y$.
class HomogeneousSpace (X : Type*) [TopologicalSpace X] : Prop where
exists_equiv : ∀ x y : X, ∃ f : X ≃ₜ X, f x = yEvery discrete space is homogeneous.
All goals completed! 🐙Problem 13 in [Ar2013]: Is it true that every infinite homogeneous compact hausdorff space contains a non-trivial convergent sequence?
@[category research open, question, AMS 54]
theorem homogeneousSpace_exists_inj_tendsto :
∀ (X : Type) (_ : TopologicalSpace X), ¬ Finite X → T2Space X → CompactSpace X →
HomogeneousSpace X → ∃ s : ℕ → X, s.Injective ∧ ∃ a : X, Tendsto s atTop (nhds a) := by ⊢ ∀ (X : Type) (x : TopologicalSpace X),
¬Finite X → T2Space X → CompactSpace X → HomogeneousSpace X → ∃ s, Function.Injective s ∧ ∃ a, Tendsto s atTop (𝓝 a)
sorry All goals completed! 🐙Problem 14 in [Ar2013]: Is it possible to represent an arbitrary compact hausdorff space as an image of a homogeneous compact space under a continuous mapping?
@[category research open, question, AMS 54]
theorem homogeneousSpace_exists_surjective :
∀ (X : Type) (_ : TopologicalSpace X), T2Space X → CompactSpace X →
∃ (Y : Type) (_ : TopologicalSpace Y), T2Space Y ∧ CompactSpace Y ∧ HomogeneousSpace Y ∧
∃ f : Y → X, Continuous f ∧ f.Surjective := by ⊢ ∀ (X : Type) (x : TopologicalSpace X),
T2Space X →
CompactSpace X →
∃ Y x_1, T2Space Y ∧ CompactSpace Y ∧ HomogeneousSpace Y ∧ ∃ f, Continuous f ∧ Function.Surjective f
sorry All goals completed! 🐙A topological space is called ω-monolithic if the closure of every countable subspace is metrizable.
class CountablyMonolithicSpace (X : Type*) [TopologicalSpace X] : Prop where
metrizable_of_closure_of_countable : ∀ ⦃s : Set X⦄, s.Countable → MetrizableSpace (closure s)Every Metrizable space is ω-monolithic.
@[category test, AMS 54]
instance MetrizableSpace.countablyMonolithicSpace
(X : Type*) [TopologicalSpace X] [MetrizableSpace X] : CountablyMonolithicSpace X := by X:Type u_1inst✝¹:TopologicalSpace Xinst✝:MetrizableSpace X⊢ CountablyMonolithicSpace X
refine { metrizable_of_closure_of_countable := ?_ } X:Type u_1inst✝¹:TopologicalSpace Xinst✝:MetrizableSpace X⊢ ∀ ⦃s : Set X⦄, s.Countable → MetrizableSpace ↑(closure[inst✝¹] s)
intros X:Type u_1inst✝¹:TopologicalSpace Xinst✝:MetrizableSpace Xs✝:Set Xa✝:s✝.Countable⊢ MetrizableSpace ↑(closure[inst✝¹] s✝)
infer_instance All goals completed! 🐙Problem 15 in [Ar2013]: Is every homogeneous ω-monolithic compact hausdorff space first countable?
@[category research open, question, AMS 54]
theorem firstCountableTopology_of_countablyMonolithicSpace :
∀ (X : Type) (_ : TopologicalSpace X), T2Space X → CompactSpace X →
HomogeneousSpace X → CountablyMonolithicSpace X → FirstCountableTopology X := by ⊢ ∀ (X : Type) (x : TopologicalSpace X),
T2Space X → CompactSpace X → HomogeneousSpace X → CountablyMonolithicSpace X → FirstCountableTopology X
sorry All goals completed! 🐙Problem 16 in [Ar2013]: Is the cardinality of every homogeneous ω-monolithic compact hausdorff space not greater than 𝔠?
@[category research open, question, AMS 54]
theorem countablyMonolithicSpace_card_lt :
∀ (X : Type) (_ : TopologicalSpace X), T2Space X → CompactSpace X →
HomogeneousSpace X → CountablyMonolithicSpace X → #X ≤ 𝔠 := by ⊢ ∀ (X : Type) (x : TopologicalSpace X),
T2Space X → CompactSpace X → HomogeneousSpace X → CountablyMonolithicSpace X → #X ≤ 𝔠
sorry All goals completed! 🐙A topological space is monolithic (see [Ar1987]; [Ar2013] uses the term without defining it) if every subspace has network weight at most its density.
class MonolithicSpace (X : Type*) [TopologicalSpace X] : Prop where
networkWeight_le_density : ∀ Y : Set X, networkWeight Y ≤ density Y
Monolithicity in the form nw(cl A) ≤ |A| + ω for every subset A.
@[category test, AMS 54]
theorem monolithicSpace_iff_networkWeight_closure_le (X : Type*) [TopologicalSpace X] :
MonolithicSpace X ↔ ∀ s : Set X, networkWeight (closure s) ≤ #s + ℵ₀ := by X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace X⊢ MonolithicSpace X ↔ ∀ (s : Set X), networkWeight ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀
constructor mp X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace X⊢ MonolithicSpace X → ∀ (s : Set X), networkWeight ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀mpr X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace X⊢ (∀ (s : Set X), networkWeight ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀) → MonolithicSpace X
· mp X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace X⊢ MonolithicSpace X → ∀ (s : Set X), networkWeight ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀ intro h s mp X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:MonolithicSpace Xs:Set X⊢ networkWeight ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀
refine (h.networkWeight_le_density _).trans ?_ mp X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:MonolithicSpace Xs:Set X⊢ density ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀
have hd : Dense ((↑) ⁻¹' s : Set (closure s)) := by X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace X⊢ MonolithicSpace X ↔ ∀ (s : Set X), networkWeight ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀ mp X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:MonolithicSpace Xs:Set Xhd:Dense (Subtype.val ⁻¹' s)⊢ density ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀
rw [Subtype.dense_iff, X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:MonolithicSpace Xs:Set X⊢ closure[inst✝] s ⊆ closure[inst✝] (Subtype.val '' Subtype.val ⁻¹' s) mp X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:MonolithicSpace Xs:Set Xhd:Dense (Subtype.val ⁻¹' s)⊢ density ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀ Subtype.image_preimage_coe, X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:MonolithicSpace Xs:Set X⊢ closure[inst✝] s ⊆ closure[inst✝] (closure[inst✝] s ∩ s)mp X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:MonolithicSpace Xs:Set Xhd:Dense (Subtype.val ⁻¹' s)⊢ density ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀ inter_eq_right.mpr subset_closure X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:MonolithicSpace Xs:Set X⊢ closure[inst✝] s ⊆ closure[inst✝] smp X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:MonolithicSpace Xs:Set Xhd:Dense (Subtype.val ⁻¹' s)⊢ density ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀]mp X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:MonolithicSpace Xs:Set Xhd:Dense (Subtype.val ⁻¹' s)⊢ density ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀mp X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:MonolithicSpace Xs:Set Xhd:Dense (Subtype.val ⁻¹' s)⊢ density ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀
exact hd.density_le.trans
(add_le_add_left (Cardinal.mk_preimage_of_injective _ _ Subtype.val_injective) _) All goals completed! 🐙
· mpr X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace X⊢ (∀ (s : Set X), networkWeight ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀) → MonolithicSpace X intro h mpr X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:∀ (s : Set X), networkWeight ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀⊢ MonolithicSpace X
refine ⟨fun Y => ?_⟩ mpr X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:∀ (s : Set X), networkWeight ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀Y:Set X⊢ networkWeight ↑Y ≤ density ↑Y
obtain ⟨D, hD, hD'⟩ := exists_dense_mk_add_aleph0_eq_density (X := Y) mpr X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:∀ (s : Set X), networkWeight ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀Y:Set XD:Set ↑YhD:Dense DhD':#↑D + ℵ₀ = density ↑Y⊢ networkWeight ↑Y ≤ density ↑Y
have hsub : Y ⊆ closure (Subtype.val '' D) := Subtype.dense_iff.mp hD mpr X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:∀ (s : Set X), networkWeight ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀Y:Set XD:Set ↑YhD:Dense DhD':#↑D + ℵ₀ = density ↑Yhsub:Y ⊆ closure[inst✝] (Subtype.val '' D)⊢ networkWeight ↑Y ≤ density ↑Y
calc networkWeight Y
≤ networkWeight (closure (Subtype.val '' D)) :=
(IsEmbedding.inclusion hsub).isInducing.networkWeight_le
_ ≤ #(Subtype.val '' D) + ℵ₀ := h _
_ = density Y := by X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:∀ (s : Set X), networkWeight ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀Y:Set XD:Set ↑YhD:Dense DhD':#↑D + ℵ₀ = density ↑Yhsub:Y ⊆ closure[inst✝] (Subtype.val '' D)⊢ #↑(Subtype.val '' D) + ℵ₀ = density ↑Y rw [Cardinal.mk_image_eq Subtype.val_injective, X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:∀ (s : Set X), networkWeight ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀Y:Set XD:Set ↑YhD:Dense DhD':#↑D + ℵ₀ = density ↑Yhsub:Y ⊆ closure[inst✝] (Subtype.val '' D)⊢ #↑D + ℵ₀ = density ↑Y All goals completed! 🐙 hD' X:Type u_1inst✝:TopologicalSpace Xh:∀ (s : Set X), networkWeight ↑(closure[inst✝] s) ≤ #↑s + ℵ₀Y:Set XD:Set ↑YhD:Dense DhD':#↑D + ℵ₀ = density ↑Yhsub:Y ⊆ closure[inst✝] (Subtype.val '' D)⊢ density ↑Y = density ↑Y All goals completed! 🐙] All goals completed! 🐙Every discrete space is monolithic.
@[category test, AMS 54]
instance DiscreteTopology.toMonolithicSpace (X : Type*) [TopologicalSpace X] [DiscreteTopology X] :
MonolithicSpace X where
networkWeight_le_density _ := by X:Type u_1inst✝¹:TopologicalSpace Xinst✝:DiscreteTopology Xx✝:Set X⊢ networkWeight ↑x✝ ≤ density ↑x✝ rw [networkWeight_discrete, X:Type u_1inst✝¹:TopologicalSpace Xinst✝:DiscreteTopology Xx✝:Set X⊢ #↑x✝ + ℵ₀ ≤ density ↑x✝ All goals completed! 🐙 density_discrete X:Type u_1inst✝¹:TopologicalSpace Xinst✝:DiscreteTopology Xx✝:Set X⊢ #↑x✝ + ℵ₀ ≤ #↑x✝ + ℵ₀ All goals completed! 🐙] All goals completed! 🐙Every second countable space is monolithic.
@[category test, AMS 54]
instance SecondCountableTopology.toMonolithicSpace (X : Type*) [TopologicalSpace X]
[SecondCountableTopology X] : MonolithicSpace X where
networkWeight_le_density _ := networkWeight_le_aleph0.trans aleph0_le_densityProblem 17 in [Ar2013]: Is it true that every nonempty monolithic compact hausdorff space contains a point with a first countable neighborhood basis?
Note: Nonempty X is required since the conclusion asserts the existence of a point.
@[category research open, question, AMS 54]
theorem monolithicSpace_exists_nhds_generated_countable :
∀ (X : Type) (_ : TopologicalSpace X), T2Space X → CompactSpace X →
Nonempty X → MonolithicSpace X → ∃ x : X, (𝓝 x).IsCountablyGenerated := by ⊢ ∀ (X : Type) (x : TopologicalSpace X),
T2Space X → CompactSpace X → Nonempty X → MonolithicSpace X → ∃ x_1, (𝓝 x_1).IsCountablyGenerated
sorry All goals completed! 🐙end Homogeneous