/-
Copyright 2026 The Formal Conjectures Authors.
Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
You may obtain a copy of the License at
https://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
limitations under the License.
-/modulepublicimportFormalConjecturesUtil
The Maxwell conjecture
References:
arXiv:2607.27197The Maxwell Conjecture is False by
Philip Arathoon, Gavin Ball and Matthew D. Kvalheim (2026)
Mystery of point charges by Andrei Gabrielov, Dmitry
Novikov and Boris Shapiro, Proc. London Math. Soc. 95 (2007), 443-472
In his 1873 Treatise on Electricity and Magnetism (§113) J. C. Maxwell discusses the number of
equilibria of the electric field generated by $n$ point charges. Based on their reading of that
passage, Gabrielov, Novikov and Shapiro formulated the Maxwell conjecture: if the critical
points of the electrostatic potential
$$V(x) = \sum_{j=1}^n \frac{q_j}{|x - a_j|}$$
generated by $n$ point charges are all non-degenerate, then their number is at most $(n-1)^2$.
Arathoon, Ball and Kvalheim disproved the conjecture by exhibiting a configuration of five
positive point charges — three unit charges at the vertices of an equilateral triangle together
with two small charges placed symmetrically on the axis of the triangle — whose potential has at
least $24$ non-degenerate critical points, whereas $(5-1)^2 = 16$.
The Coulomb potential $V(x) = \sum_j q_j / |x - a_j|$ generated by $n$ point charges of
strengths $q_j$ located at the points $a_j$ of Euclidean $3$-space. It is genuinely defined
away from the charge locations $a_j$.
The equilibria of the field of $n$ point charges: the points where the electric field
$-\nabla V$ vanishes, i.e. the critical points of the potential $V$, away from the charges
themselves.
Maxwell's conjecture, in the formulation of Gabrielov, Novikov and Shapiro: if the
critical points of the electrostatic potential generated by $n$ point charges (at distinct
locations, with non-zero strengths) are all non-degenerate, then their number cannot exceed
$(n-1)^2$.
The second half of Theorem 1 of Arathoon–Ball–Kvalheim: after a small perturbation of the
charge strengths, the counterexample potential is a Morse function, i.e. it has finitely many
critical points, all of which are non-degenerate, and there are still at least $24$ of them.
Maxwell's conjecture is false: Arathoon, Ball and Kvalheim exhibit five point charges whose
potential is a Morse function with at least $24 > 16 = (5-1)^2$ critical points.
The positions of the five charges of the counterexample: three vertices of an equilateral
triangle in the plane $z = 0$, together with the two points $(0, 0, \pm\varepsilon)$ on its
axis of symmetry.
The strengths of the five charges of the counterexample: three unit charges at the vertices
of the triangle and two charges of strength
$q_\varepsilon = \frac{3}{4}\varepsilon^3 - \frac{5}{32}\varepsilon^5$ on the axis.
The first three charges of the counterexample sit at the vertices of an equilateral triangle
of side length $\sqrt{3}$, inscribed in the unit circle of the plane $z = 0$.
The last two charges of the counterexample are placed symmetrically about the origin on the
axis of the triangle, at distance $2|\varepsilon|$ from each other.
Theorem 1 of Arathoon–Ball–Kvalheim: there is an $\varepsilon_0 > 0$ such that for all
$0 < \varepsilon < \varepsilon_0$ the potential generated by the five charges located at
$a_1, \dots, a_5$ with respective strengths $1, 1, 1, q_\varepsilon, q_\varepsilon$, where
$q_\varepsilon = \frac{3}{4}\varepsilon^3 - \frac{5}{32}\varepsilon^5$, admits at least $24$
non-degenerate critical points.
Lemma 2 of Arathoon–Ball–Kvalheim: the polynomial $\Phi_0$ has exactly $21$ critical points,
all of which are non-degenerate. These are the critical points into which the central
equilibrium of the equilateral triangle bifurcates when the two axial charges are added.
Proposition 1 of Arathoon–Ball–Kvalheim: iterating the construction, for every $m \geq 0$
there is a configuration of $3 + 2m$ positive point charges whose potential has a finite number
$k \geq 4 + 20m$ of critical points, all of which are non-degenerate. In particular the ratio
of critical points to charges is asymptotically at least $10$.
Maxwell's conjecture holds for three point charges of equal magnitudes: the potential of three
such charges, if all of its critical points are non-degenerate, has at most $(3-1)^2 = 4$ of
them.
Maxwell's conjecture for three point charges of arbitrary strengths: if all critical points of
the potential of three point charges are non-degenerate, then there are at most $(3-1)^2 = 4$ of
them. This remains open.
Is the number of equilibria of $n$ point charges bounded by a polynomial in $n$?
With the quadratic bound of Maxwell's conjecture gone, the gap between the known bounds is
wide: the constructions of Arathoon–Ball–Kvalheim give configurations with at least $10n$
equilibria asymptotically, while the best known upper bounds — $2^{2n^2}(3n)^{2n}$ by
Gabrielov–Novikov–Shapiro, $5 \cdot 9^{3+n}$ by Zolotov and $2^n (3n-2)^3$ by
Edelsbrunner–Fillmore–Oliveira — are all exponential in $n$.