/- Copyright 2026 The Formal Conjectures Authors. Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License"); you may not use this file except in compliance with the License. You may obtain a copy of the License at https://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0 Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS, WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied. See the License for the specific language governing permissions and limitations under the License. -/ module public import FormalConjecturesUtil meta import FormalConjecturesForMathlib.Combinatorics.SimpleGraph.Connectivity meta import FormalConjecturesForMathlib.Combinatorics.SimpleGraph.HarmonicIndex meta import FormalConjecturesForMathlib.Combinatorics.SimpleGraph.Saturation

TxGraffiti Conjecture 4: the saturation number versus the harmonic index

Reference: arxiv/2507.17780 In Reverie Together: Ten Years of Mathematical Discovery with a Machine Collaborator by Randy Davila, Boris Brimkov, Ryan Pepper

TxGraffiti is an automated conjecturing program, a successor of Fajtlowicz's Graffiti and DeLaViña's Graffiti.pc. Conjecture 4 in the cited collection asserts a bound between two graph invariants:

    the saturation number $\mu^*(G)$ (SimpleGraph.saturationNumber), the minimum number of edges in a maximal matching of $G$;

    the harmonic index $H(G)$ (SimpleGraph.harmonicIndex), $\sum_{uv \in E(G)} 2 / (\deg u + \deg v)$.

The conjecture is false. It was first refuted by Bıyıkoğlu, who exhibited a family of counterexamples — a disjoint union of edges joined to an independent set — with unbounded ratio $\mu^*/H$. That the smallest counterexample has order $9$, namely the friendship graph $F_4$ formalised below, and that the windmill family has an exact limiting ratio, are established in Gupta.

References:

@[expose] public sectionopen SimpleGraphnamespace Arxiv.«2507.17780»

The friendship graph $F_4$: a hub vertex $0$ joined to four triangles, whose rims are the pairs ${1,2}, {3,4}, {5,6}, {7,8}$. It has $12$ edges on $9$ vertices ($8$ spokes and $4$ rim edges).

def friendshipF4 : SimpleGraph (Fin 9) := fromEdgeSet { s(0, 1), s(0, 2), s(0, 3), s(0, 4), s(0, 5), s(0, 6), s(0, 7), s(0, 8), s(1, 2), s(3, 4), s(5, 6), s(7, 8) }instance : DecidableRel friendshipF4.Adj := ⊢ DecidableRel friendshipF4.Adj ⊢ DecidableRel (fromEdgeSet {s(0, 1), s(0, 2), s(0, 3), s(0, 4), s(0, 5), s(0, 6), s(0, 7), s(0, 8), s(1, 2), s(3, 4), s(5, 6), s(7, 8)}).Adj; All goals completed! 🐙

TxGraffiti Conjecture 4: for every nontrivial connected graph $G$, the saturation number is at most the harmonic index, $\mu^*(G) \le H(G)$.

This conjecture is FALSE.

Counterexample. The friendship graph $F_4$ (friendshipF4) is connected and nontrivial, with $\mu^(F_4) = 4$ and $H(F_4) = 18/5$. Indeed the four rim edges ${1,2}, {3,4}, {5,6}, {7,8}$ form a maximal matching of size $4$, and no maximal matching is smaller, so $\mu^(F_4) = 4$; the eight spokes contribute $2/(8+2) = 1/5$ each and the four rim edges contribute $2/(2+2) = 1/2$ each, giving $H(F_4) = 8 \cdot 1/5 + 4 \cdot 1/2 = 18/5$. Since $4 > 18/5$, the bound fails.

More generally the friendship graphs $F_k$ satisfy $\mu^(F_k) = k$ and $H(F_k) = 2k/(k+1) + k/2$, so the conjecture fails for every $k \ge 4$. An exhaustive search confirms that $F_4$ is the smallest counterexample (order $9$). The unbounded separation was first shown by Bıyıkoğlu, whose family of edges joined to an independent set makes $\mu^/H$ arbitrarily large; the windmill generalisation and its exact limit appear in arXiv:2606.15761.

h:∀ (V : Type) [inst : Fintype V] [inst_1 : DecidableEq V] [Nontrivial V] (G : SimpleGraph V) [inst_3 : DecidableRel G.Adj], G.Connected → ↑G.saturationNumber ≤ G.harmonicIndexkey:↑friendshipF4.computableSaturationNumber ≤ friendshipF4.harmonicIndex⊢ False h:∀ (V : Type) [inst : Fintype V] [inst_1 : DecidableEq V] [Nontrivial V] (G : SimpleGraph V) [inst_3 : DecidableRel G.Adj], G.Connected → ↑G.saturationNumber ≤ G.harmonicIndex⊢ ↑friendshipF4.computableSaturationNumber ≤ friendshipF4.harmonicIndex → False All goals completed! 🐙end Arxiv.«2507.17780»